Kalshi Faces New York Shutdown Risk After Federal Court Sends Case to State Court
Summary
- The U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York sent the Kalshi case back to New York state court, increasing the risk of an operating shutdown.
- New York is seeking to halt Kalshi's event-contract trading on the grounds that it constitutes gambling, while Kalshi has argued its business is legal because it is overseen by the CFTC.
- The CFTC said Kalshi could be forced to suspend its entire business if New York halts the trading, and the dispute over regulatory authority for prediction markets is spreading across the U.S.
Forecast Trend Report by Period



Prediction market platform Kalshi faces a rising risk of business disruption after failing to keep a lawsuit over New York state's push to shut down its operations in federal court.
CoinDesk reported on November 20 that the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York decided a day earlier to send New York state's case against Kalshi back to state court. The court said the dispute should be heard in state, not federal, court.
The decision clears the way for New York authorities to press ahead with legal efforts to halt Kalshi's event-contract trading. New York argues that prediction-market trading tied to outcomes such as sports games and political elections amounts to gambling and is subject to state regulation.
New York Attorney General Letitia James sued Kalshi in July, alleging that the company was operating an illegal gambling business. The New York State Gaming Commission had previously ordered Kalshi to stop operating, but Kalshi has challenged the state's authority, arguing that it is a federally regulated exchange overseen by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission.
The ruling could have broad consequences because Kalshi is headquartered in New York. In a filing submitted to federal court on November 20, the CFTC said Kalshi may have to suspend its entire business if New York succeeds in stopping its event-contract trading.
The CFTC also argued that Kalshi's event contracts could qualify as swaps under federal commodities law and that regulatory authority therefore rests with federal authorities. It sought a temporary restraining order to block New York state's cease-and-desist action, but the federal judge denied the request during a phone hearing later that day.
The New York Attorney General's office also submitted a proposed temporary restraining order to temporarily halt Kalshi's trading. No shutdown order has been issued so far, and related legal proceedings are still underway.
Kalshi says it has operated lawfully under the federal regulatory framework. Spokeswoman Elizabeth Diana said the company was approved as a federally regulated exchange during the Biden administration and has complied with the law from the start. Kalshi will work with the state to find a solution that protects the interests of its 1.2 million New York users, she added.
Meanwhile, the fight over who has the authority to regulate prediction markets is spreading across the U.S. A third federal appeals court this week also rejected Kalshi's argument that only the CFTC has jurisdiction over prediction-market regulation. With courts reaching different conclusions, the issue could ultimately be decided by the U.S. Supreme Court.